header image

March 31: Hamlet~

Posted by: nicsnotation | April 23, 2008 | 8 Comments |



~ “All the world’s a stage,/And all the men and women merely players;/They have their exits and their entrances,/And one man in his time plays many parts,/His acts being seven ages.” (William Shakespeare) ~ 

      There is a major difference between sympathy and empathy. There is a major difference between comprehending and connecting. So if you were to ask me, “How do you feel about Hamlet and the situation he is in?” I would answer, “I sympathize and can comprehend what position he is in.” We have only read a portion of the play so far, but already Hamlet is in a bit of a mess. His dad was dead at the beginning, and so Hamlet came home to mourn for him and claim the crown, only to find his mother married to his uncle and Denmark in a party state. Then, to add to his troubles, he sees the ghost of his father, who claims he was murdered by his brother. Not knowing whether to trust the ghost, and not being able to trust his former friends or girlfriend, Hamlet is awfully alone. With the exception of Horatio, Hamlet has no one to turn to, not even his own mother. This is enough to make anyone depressed or go mad- this I can sympathize with, As for empathy, I have no idea what it would be like to be in Hamlet’s shoes.

       If I were placed in Hamlet’s position, of course I would doubt what the ghost was telling me and asking me to do. I would be suspicious, because back then going to heaven or hell after death was a huge issue, and murder would cause someone to go to hell. So, why would my father, someone who has guided me my whole life and encouraged me to make positive decisions, pave for me the way to hell? And of course, the ghost is assuming the physical appearance of my father, so how could I deny him of my service? It seems to me like the ghost is the first thing that happens to Hamlet that makes rest of the play into a tragedy. So if I were Hamlet, I would consider long and hard about what the ghost is asking of him to decide what action is appropriate. In my opinion, Hamlet has done this- it isn’t quite procrastination.

       Although I do not have an understanding of the meaning behind Hamlet’s thoughts and actions, I do appreciate his words written through Shakespeare. A monologue I particularly enjoyed is where the famous “To be or not to be” quote comes from. In the video below, I recited his words.

CLICK HERE TO VIEW VIDEO

under: ~ELA B30 Assign~

Responses - Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)

Very good respnse keep up the good work! lol

I hope that video you are going to put up is one you did by yourself and not one that you, krysta and I did.

Oh shoot, I forgot to mention that. Oh well, for those that read my comments, Steph, Krysta and I once did a video reading of the quote… okay, I forced Steph and Krysta to do it with me. Lol, it was in the summer, and I wanted to know what the play Macbeth entailed…
And I’m sorry, Steph, I deleted it!

Hey Nic, I totally agree with what you said about sympathizing for Hamlet, though you couldn’t necessarily empathize with him. His situation is one that we have never been in, so it is really hard to say how we would react. Everyone can judge Hamlet as much as they want, but it truly isn’t fair if they have never experienced what Hamlet experienced.
It was interesting how you said you wouldn’t trust the ghost because you didn’t think that he should be telling you to committ a murder and go to hell. I don’t think that question would come across in this play though, because obviously, avenging deaths was a common every day thing to do. All you hd to do was confess your sins and repent them. It was expected of people to seek revenge. I do agree though that Hamlet isn’t really procrastinating. He isn’t sure of what to do and he is weighing his options. If he would have acted quickly, people then would have accused him of being rash. Poor Hamlet just couldn’t win!

Great Job! :)

Doing good!

Hamlet in my opinion is somewhat procrastinating because he would have had to made up his mind when he killed Poloniuos (sp?). When he saw Claudius alone in the hall, he thought of killing him but then soon withdrew his decision and moved on. Shortly after, he was talking to his mom and when she called for help, SOMEONE behind the curtins or what ever and Hamlet right away stabed him. He must have made up his mind fast after the hall scene to the closet scene.

Hey Tyler and Megan, thanks for the comments. I totally agree with what you two are saying about it not being weird that the ghost is asking Hamlet to avenge his death. However, if it were me in that situation, today I would be a little suspicious. Good thoughts generated on the whole procrastination thing, I’m loving reading what everyone has to say!

Nic,

You know, I think you’d be surprised to know that you have more comments on your blog than anyone else! lol Is it because you have such an interesting, engaging blog, or you are responding quickly to their posts and comments, or … are you paying them? lol

The video of your soliloquy is up and running now. Once in YouTube, search keenermarc and it will come up with a list of my uploaded videos. Yours should be at the top as the most recent.

Very interesting project, you did there. lol I’ve smiled thinking over it a few times now. I think that’s really awesome that you wanted to do that. Are you sure a Lit Degree isn’t somewhere in your future? hmm? ;)

Lol, is that one of your nagging questions?
Thanks for uploading that video!! I didn’t watch it before, so I guess the camera cut out the end when I finished and blew out the candle.. oh well, it was fun to do no matter the result.

Leave a response - Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)

Your response:

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image

Categories